| Rev. Albert | 1865-1869 |
| Rev. F. Kern | 1869-1872 |
| Rev. F. Reinicke | 1872-1895 |
| Rev. F. Werhahn | 1896-1910 |
| Rev. August Koepp | 1910-1923 |
| Rev. A.W. Scharfe | 1923-1927 |
| Rev. Jacob Reiff | 1927-1945 |
| Rev. Edmund Baumgarten | 1945-1950 |
| Rev. B. F. Matter | 1950-1957 |
| Rev. Floyd Olson | 1957-1961 |
| Rev. Merlin Bartelt | 1961-1965 |
| Rev. Marloe Karlen | 1965-1974 |
| Rev. Steve Jacobsen | 1974-1977 |
| Rev. Jon Becker | 1978-1981 |
| Rev. Eric Burtness | 1982-1984 |
| Rev. Frank Kauzlarich | 1985-1991 |
| Rev. Paul Gammelin | 1991-1997 |
| Rev. Tim Greenwald | 1998-2006 |
| Rev. Dan Sire | 2007-2021 |
| Rev. Maggie Westaby | 2022-Present |